MAKING YOUR MONEY WORK FOR YOU
Maybe you’re thinking it’s time to review your investment strategy and make the most of the money you have today. Maybe you’ve already built a financially successful retirement egg and want to protect what you’ve built. Or maybe you need to bulk up your earnings to ensure your family’s future.
Welcome to money for grown-ups. Where do you turn for credible information?
Dedicated to helping you protect your assets, stretch your dollars, and bolster your longterm security, AARP can offer you powerful solutions. Whatever your strategy for managing money, we’ve got suggestions that will help – from saving money on that next big purchase to planning your charitable giving. If you’re taking your job to the next level or building up a second career, we’ve got strategies that will help you make your mark.
You may think your money — or your financial advisor — should be working harder for you. You may be watching market trends and seeing new opportunities. And, of course, you want to protect yourself and your loved ones from scams and data breaches. We can give you the support you need.
And turn to us for fun, too. (Is it time for that car, that trip, that weekend home you’ve always wanted?) Because that, too, is what this time of your life is about.
AARP is a nonprofit, nonpartisan membership organization that helps people
50 and older improve their lives. For more than 50 years, AARP has been serving
our members and society by creating positive social change. AARP’s mission
is to enhance the quality of life for all as we age; lead positive social change;
and deliver value to members through information, service and advocacy. This
information in this book is for educational purposes and does not constitute
financial advice.
Table of Contents
Title Page
Copyright Page
Dedication
Epigraph
PREFACE
Acknowledgements
Introduction
PART ONE - A RICH MIND
ARE YOU SUFFERING FROM AFFLUENZA?
WHY MONEY WON’T GET YOU TO “LEVEL THREE”
THE GREAT MYSTERY
THE DECENT DRAPERY OF LIFE
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GETTING RICH AND BEING RICH
THE KEY TO PERFECT FREEDOM
THE SECRET OF INSPIRATIONAL LEADERSHIP
ARE YOU ONE OF THE 4 PERCENT?
FINDING MEANING IN THE SECOND HALF OF LIFE
THE VALUE OF BEING UTTERLY, GLORIOUSLY WRONG
ADVICE FROM A 2000-YEAR-OLD SLAVE
THE HARDEST VICTORY
IN PRAISE OF DIFFICULT PLEASURES
THE TRUE GENTLEMAN
BEYOND SELF-ACTUALIZATION
THE LAST LESSON OF CULTURE
WEALTH THAT CAN’T BE TALLIED
STUMBLING ON HAPPINESS
THE TRUE MEANING OF SUCCESS
PART TWO - WHAT MATTERS MOST
WHAT’S ON YOUR BUCKET LIST?
HOW TO CALCULATE YOUR REAL WEALTH
THE MOST VALUABLE THING YOU OWN
THE BIGGEST QUESTION
DREAMS WITH DEADLINES
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL PLACE ON EARTH?
HOW TO AVOID “THE MAÑANA SYNDROME”
GENTLEMEN, STOP YOUR ENGINES!
ENJOY EVERY SANDWICH
THE BEST SPIRITUAL ADVICE
CAN A MOZART VIOLIN SONATA CHANGE YOUR LIFE?
HOW TO TRANSFORM YOUR LIFE
SIX STEPS TO A MORE RELAXED LIFE
ONE OF THE BEST SECRETS OF LIFE
THIS VIEW OF LIFE
WHY I HOPE STEVE JOBS IS WRONG
A RESOLUTION WORTH KEEPING
A THORN WITH EVERY ROSE
THE BEST WAY OUT
PART THREE - ATTITUDES AND GRATITUDE
WHAT MATTERS MOST
THE LAST HUMAN FREEDOM
WHY YOU SHOULD THINK BEFORE YOU “BLINK”
THE MOST STUPID OF VICES
THE PSYCHOLOGY OF OPTIMAL EXPERIENCE
THE COURAGE OF RANDY PAUSCH
ARE YOU READY FOR THE 21-DAY CHALLENGE?
NO SUCH THING AS A BAD DAY
THE ANTIDOTE FOR GREED
THE GREATEST VIRTUE... AND THE FIRST
WHO’S YOUR CITY?
THE HEALING OF KAREN ARMSTRONG
THE CHEAPEST MEDICINE . . . AND THE BEST
THE SCIENCE OF GIVING
ARE YOU KEEPING THE EMBERS ALIVE?
PART FOUR - THE SEARCH FOR MEANING
DISCOVERING THE LAWS OF LIFE
THE SAGE OF MONTICELLO
THE WOLF IN MONK’S ROBES
FROM GRAND TRUTHS TO GRAND CAVERNS
THE GREAT DISCONNECT
THE ATHEIST AND THE APOLOGIST
GUIDEPOSTS ON THE FOOTPATH TO PEACE
TWO GREAT THINKERS ON “THE GOOD LIFE”
THE FORMULA FOR RE-ENCHANTMENT
IN PRAISE OF LIFELONG LEARNING
THE MYSTERIUM TREMENDUM . . . AND YOU
MY KIND OF MARTYR
FINDING MEANING IN AN AGE OF DOUBT
RENEWING A FORGOTTEN VIRTUE
THE SECRET OF SHELTER ISLAND
AFTERWORD
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
INDEX
For Hannah and David
Money has yet to make anyone rich.
PREFACE
After more than 25 years of virtually uninterrupted prosperity, the U.S. economy has hit a rough patch.
As I write, jobless claims are at a 27-year high. Consumer confidence is at an all-time low. Credit is tight. Business investment and personal spending have plunged. Housing is in a death spiral. The U.S. auto industry is on the verge of collapse. And the stock market just experienced its worst year since 1931.
Welcome to The Great Recession.
There’s nothing funny, of course, about losing your job, getting evicted, or watching your net worth plummet. Economic downturns bring pain and suffering. There will be plenty of belt-tightening—and sober reflection—in the months ahead.
But to the extent recessions shake up the status quo and force us to examine our goals and priorities, they also offer enormous opportunities.
This book is meant to aid in that process. The Secret of Shelter Island is partly about money. But it is also about putting it—and the rest of your life—in perspective.
There has rarely been a better time to do so. We are experiencing a financial slump unlike any in modern times. Virtually every investor has seen his net worth get a serious haircut.
How did we get here? There is plenty of blame to go around, starting with reckless lenders, overly ambitious borrowers, unethical CEOs, feckless investors, and shortsighted policy makers.
Too many were chasing the fast buck, took momentary leave of their senses, or abandoned their basic values. This is especially true on Wall Street. Vanguard Founder John Bogle hits the nail on the head in his book Enough:
“Not knowing what enough is subverts our professional values. It makes salespersons of those who should be fiduciaries of the investments entrusted to them. It turns a system that should be built on trust into one with counting as its foundation. Worse, this confusion about enough leads us astray in our larger lives. We chase the false rabbits of success; we too often bow down at the altar of the transitory and finally meaningless and fail to cherish what is beyond calculation, indeed eternal.”
In many ways, enough is a central message of this book. Even during this historic downturn, most Americans have ample material wealth. (Covering our basic needs just doesn’t take that much.) But how about the immaterial?
What is your animating purpose? How are you spending your time? What are you living for?
Many of us—perhaps especially those with a newfound hole in their retirement account, financial plan, or tuition fund—are reap-praising these questions now.
This book may help you see—or consider—things differently. It consists primarily of essays I wrote for Spiritual Wealth, a weekly e-letter that seeks “The Road Map to a Rich Life.” If you’re a new reader, welcome. If you’re a regular reader, welcome back.
The Secret of Shelter Island is arranged around four central themes: A Rich Mind, What Matters Most, Attitudes and Gratitude, and The Search for Meaning. My objective here is to share some insights about “the big questions”—and perhaps provide a bit of inspiration, something we could all use in a world that bombards us with sad and tragic news.
If you’re like me, you’re tired of hearing about wild-eyed terrorists, drug-addled celebrities, ethically challenged businessmen and crooked politicians. The national media delivers a daily dose of heartbreak, misery, and cynicism. Much of what we watch and read each day is depressing, even rattling.
I wrote these essays as an antidote. They consist solely of ideas I’ve found particularly inspiring, elevating, or ennobling.
Over the last thirty years, I’ve spent a great deal of time studying history, philosophy, psychology, science and religion, saving and highlighting virtually everything I read. This project gave me the opportunity to revisit those classic works and cite some of the best minds and ideas of all time.
You’ll notice that these pages lean heavily on quotes and sources from antiquity. Why? When it comes to wisdom about how to live your life, the best ideas are not new. As Ralph Waldo Emerson said, “All my best thoughts were stolen by the ancients.”
Second, authoritative historical sources give more heft to anyone’s point of view. I’ve found you don’t get much opposition to ideas attributed to Cicero, Aristotle, or Epictetus. (Who really wants to argue with Marcus Aurelius?)
Judging by my mailbag, there is a great thirst out there for this kind of knowledge. Writers are always hearing from their readers, of course. But even in the glory days of the last bull market—or the depths of the previous bear—I never received an avalanche like this.
Readers told me these essays inspired them, motivated them, caused them to end a bad relationship, start a new career, forgive an old grudge, or spend a moment appreciating their incredible good fortune, whatever their current financial status.
They sent me books, poems, photographs, speaking invitations, and handwritten letters, some several pages long.
I was overwhelmed with the response. Not just emotionally, but physically. My publisher estimates that we received over 10,000 emails from readers in the first few months alone. It was simply not possible to respond to them all. Especially since, except for a copy editor who gives my columns the once-over for grammatical and typographical errors, I had no real staff for this project. My primary occupation is logging several thousand words of investment commentary each week. Spiritual Wealth is just a sideline, one that my publisher likes to remind me has never produced a penny of revenue.
Still, I enjoyed researching and writing these pieces—and learned a lot in the process. Now I’m pleased to share them with you.
And I think the moment is right. Given recent events, this is a particularly opportune time to consider the innate connection between money, values, and the pursuit of the good life.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I could never have written this book without the fine words and great ideas of some of history’s best thinkers. We are all truly standing on the shoulders of giants.
I would also like to thank several more contemporary writers who have helped shape my views, including Karen Armstrong, Joseph Campbell, Huston Smith, Thich Nhat Hanh, Laurence G. Boldt, Jack Kornfield, Eckhart Tolle, John Horgan, Martin Seligman, Paul Kurtz, Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Carl Sagan, Charles Murray, Nathaniel Branden, Stephen Jay Gould, Sam Harris, David McCullough, Christopher Hitchens, Gregg Easterbrook, George Will, Steven R. Covey, Matthew Kelly, Daniel Gilbert, Michael Shermer, James Hollis, and Timothy Ferris.
Particular thanks to British author Bryan Magee for his excellent memoir Confessions of a Philosopher.
(I would also like to state, for the record, that I hate Bill Bryson. All writers should. If you don’t know why, read everything he’s written.)
Many thanks to Mrs. Gant, my high school English teacher, who inspired me—and paid me the biggest compliment of my 17-year-old life—when she asked whether I “planned to do anything” with my writing.
(And to the career counselor at Furman University who suggested I had a better chance of playing third base for the Yankees than earning a living wage as a writer, let me add—with all due respect—nah nah nah boo boo.)
It has been my exceptional good fortune to work with Julia Guth, Bill Bonner, Mark Ford, Myles Norin, and my other colleagues, mentors, and good friends at Agora Publishing. (Many thanks to Steven King, Alex Wissel, Christina Olson, Alex Williams, Chris Matthai, Katherine Schildt, and Matt Weinschenk for putting up with me every day.) What a great bunch of people and inspiring place to work, even though our marketing remains minimal, constrained, and hopelessly understated.
Thanks, too, to my publishers and editors at John Wiley & Sons, including Debra Englander and Kelly O’Connor, who reviewed this manuscript and recommended some important changes and clarifications.
I would also like to thank my regular readers at The Oxford Club, Investment U, and Spiritual Wealth. Without an audience, a writer is just an opinionated crank. (We’re opinionated cranks anyway, of course.)
Let me doff my hat to my good friends Mark Skousen and Rob Fix. Our many private debates—I’m still wiping the spittle off my windshield, Rob—helped sharpen my own views on many philosophical and religious matters.
Special thanks to my parents Braxton and Judith Green who, through their positive spirit and attitude toward life, taught me the best things I know. They and my wife, Karen; daughter, Hannah; and son, David are my greatest treasure—and my real source of wealth.
INTRODUCTION
When I stepped down from the podium in Phoenix, the applause from the audience of more than 600 was still ringing in my ears.
Readers were in high spirits. And why not? It was 2007 and for five straight years we had enjoyed a smooth rise in stock and bond prices.
Markets were good. Our portfolios were flush with profits. And my investment letter, The Oxford Club Communique, had been singled out by the independent Hulbert Financial Digest as one of the top letters in the country for five-year performance for two years running.
This didn’t stop a nattily dressed older gentleman from buttonholing me in the lobby with some choice words, however.
“Money, money, money, money,” he said with rising emphasis, stabbing a finger toward my chest. “You’ve made me a lot of money over the years. But let me ask, do you ever think about anything else?”
At first I thought he was kidding. He wasn’t. He just stood there in front of me, wide-eyed.
I’m used to getting feedback—both positive and negative—from readers who follow my investment advice. But I’d never had one baldly suggest that I was obsessed with money to the exclusion of everything else.
And he was dead serious. He stood there, patiently waiting for my response.
Do I ever think about anything other than money? How do you answer a question like that?
I remember wondering what had prompted the question. After all, we’d only just met. He knew me solely from my writing and lectures. Then it dawned on me . . .
For the previous seven years, I had dutifully churned out eight investment columns and articles a week—over 400 a year—with endless commentary on interest rates, currencies, stocks, bonds, commodities, mutual funds, hedge funds, convertibles, annuities, options, futures, diversification, asset allocation, takeovers, share buybacks, trailing stops, hot IPOs, how to increase returns, lower risks, reduce costs, minimize taxes, and so on.
Most of my pieces are short. And I try to keep them light and entertaining. Yet there was no denying that the primary subject of each of my previous 3,000 or so columns—not to mention every lecture, radio and television appearance—was exactly the same: money. How to make it. How to save it. How to invest it. How to multiply it.
I make no apologies for this, incidentally.
In more ways than I can enumerate, money is important. We all want to better our lives and our children’s lives. We have a natural desire to experience the best that life has to offer. We want to live in good neighborhoods. Travel to new places. Try different things. Send our kids and grandkids to better schools. These things, you may have noticed, take money.
Money grants you the power to make important choices in your life. As I emphasized in my last book The Gone Fishin’ Portfolio ( John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2008), financial independence is a worthwhile goal. It enables you to do what you want, where you want, with whom you want.
Still, I’ve never believed that getting, saving, spending, and investing are the most important things in life. Yet apparently I had created this impression with at least one reader—and probably more.
He remained steadfast in front of me, awaiting my reply. But he didn’t get one—not a good one, anyway—until I began writing a new column a few weeks later, one he had inadvertently inspired.
When I broached the idea of a new “more meaningful” writing project with my publisher, Julia Guth, she seemed open-minded.
“What will these columns be about?”
I told her they would touch on money, but also things more important than money.
She looked intrigued, but skeptical. We’re financial publishers. Our product is investment research and analysis, not musings about “the good life.”
“But what are you going to say?” she persisted.
“I don’t know yet,” I confessed. “I’ll have to write a few to find out.”
She gave me a sideways glance. “You’re not going to pull a Jerry Seinfeld on me and write about nothing are you?”
I assured her that, at the very least, each column would be about something. About what, exactly? I still wasn’t sure.
Nor had I considered what to call a column by an investment analyst, written primarily for business and financial readers, dealing only tangentially with money.
Fortunately, a title popped into my head almost immediately: True Wealth. Everyone understands the pursuit of financial wealth. I would write about combining that with nonmaterial blessings too. True wealth.
It was perfect. There was only one small problem. My friend and colleague Steve Sjuggerud already owned the True Wealth trademark. He writes an investment letter by that name. (A good one, incidentally.) But it’s about money, not things more important than money.
So what would I call this new column, one that wasn’t devoted exclusively to financial matters? At some point I realized that if I wasn’t writing about material wealth, I should just call it Spiritual Wealth.
My publisher, a spiritual sort (if I may say so), loved the title. But she was The Lone Ranger. Most everyone else in my office was negative, confused, or skeptical. None of them, however, suggested a better name.
A few days before kickoff, I was chatting with fellow editor Eric Frye at a company cocktail party. I told him about my latest project.
“Spiritual Wealth?” he asked in amazement. “Man, I wouldn’t use that word.”
“You mean spiritual?” I said.
“Yeah,” he said with a laugh. “That’s dynamite.”
I was beginning to have reservations. Why was this word so controversial?
It didn’t take long to find out. As soon as we announced Spiritual Wealth—before we published a single column—I began receiving letters from regular readers who told me in no uncertain terms that they weren’t about to listen to me—an investment analyst, for Pete’s sake—lecture them about spiritual matters.
I had no intention of doing any such thing. But they never discovered that. The word carries certain connotations and their minds were made up.
Fortunately, these letters were a distinct minority. The vast majority of respondents loved having an opportunity to ruminate about what I call “The Great Ideas.” In just a few weeks, we received thousands of testimonials.
At financial conferences, I began receiving ten comments about Spiritual Wealth for every comment about my other writing projects—the ones that actually pay the bills—combined.
People really are passionate about hearing and discussing these ideas.
And the letters kept pouring in. Many asked whether we intended to compile these essays into a book. Quite frankly, we hadn’t. But readers asked so frequently, I began thinking it might be a good idea.
Most of us devote a substantial percentage of our waking hours to making, spending or having more. The desire to accumulate is natural, of course. But when a bigger bank balance—or the things it can buy—becomes our animating purpose, disappointment generally follows.
The Secret of Shelter Island is about recognizing the importance of money, but also the primacy of honoring and fighting for your highest potential, living the life you want, doing work you enjoy, paying attention to your highest goals and values.
Material wealth alone doesn’t bring lasting satisfaction. And neither will nonmaterial blessings if you’re wondering where you’re going to get this month’s rent. But combine a sensible approach to money with good choices about nonfinancial matters and the result is the best of all worlds.
That is the essential idea in these essays. Each one was written to stand alone, however, so feel free to skip around if you’re so inclined.
Oh, and to the gentleman in Phoenix who wanted to know whether I ever think about anything besides money, let me just say yes—and thanks for asking.
PART ONE
A RICH MIND
By the time we reach adulthood, we have all developed a specific attitude toward—and relationship with—money.
This is especially true in my case. For the past 24 years, thinking about money has been my full-time job.
I spent 16 years as a research analyst, investment advisor, and portfolio manager. And in the eight years since I retired from Wall Street, I’ve been living what I call “the second half of my life,” writing about world financial markets.
From an early age we’re taught that the best things in life are free, that money can’t buy happiness, that it can’t buy love . . . and so forth. These thoughts are commonplace because they’re true.
But that’s not the whole story.
Money is the most egalitarian force in society, bestowing power on whoever holds it. It gives you the freedom to make important choices in your life. No one is truly free who is a slave to his job, his creditors, his circumstances, or his overhead.
Money may not buy happiness, but it sure steamrolls a whole lot of problems. As essayist Logan Pearsall Smith pointed out, “There are few sorrows, however poignant, in which a good income is of no avail.”
Money also makes it easier to relax, to experience peace of mind. As author Tom Robbins notes, “There’s a certain Buddhistic calm that comes from having money in the bank.”
Overcoming money worries allows you to get on with your life and focus on the people and activities you love. To pretend this isn’t so can be a form of denial, a sort of spiritual snobbery. Or it may mean that a lifetime of comfortable living has blinded us to the hardships that exist without it.
Money is freedom. It’s power, in the best sense. It allows you to support worthy causes and help those in need. It enables you to spend your life the way you want.
Of course, it would probably take a lot of money for you to have and do everything you want. That may not be possible. More importantly, it may not be desirable.
As J. Brotherton said, “My riches consist not in the extent of my possessions, but in the fewness of my wants.”
Once you start accumulating a bit of money, in fact, you’re faced with a new set of problems and responsibilities. You have to grow and protect it. You have to manage risk, stay ahead of inflation and the taxman. You have to decide whom to give it to and when.
These issues were the subject of my previous book, The Gone Fishin’ Portfolio: Get Wise, Get Wealthy . . . and Get On With Your Life.
In this book, I want to share a more personal philosophy of money . . . and of life.
What does money mean to you? What are you working for, saving for? How are you managing your relationship with money? How important is it in your life? What is it giving you? What is it costing you?
These are deeply personal issues. No one can simply hand you the answers. But it never hurts to consider the questions.
ARE YOU SUFFERING FROM AFFLUENZA?
In his 1997 film Affluenza, producer John de Graaf claims there is a virus loose in society that threatens our wallets, our friendships, our families, our communities, and our environment.
Each year it costs us hundreds of billions of dollars, wastes our precious time, ruins our health, and adversely affects our quality of life. What is affluenza, exactly?
De Graff defines it as “a painful, contagious, socially-transmitted condition of overload, debt, anxiety and waste resulting from the dogged pursuit of more.”
He argues that too many of us are working ourselves to death to accumulate an endless array of goods and services we don’t really need.
This creates stress. Stress, in turn, creates health problems, including headaches, stomachaches, ulcers, depression, even heart attacks.
Medical research shows that people in industrial nations lose more years from disability and premature death due to stress-related illnesses than other ailments.
Affluenza drives up healthcare costs, tears at the fabric of families, and shortens our stay on the right side of the daisies.
Before you mistake me for the national scold, however, let me make a couple of confessions.
First off, I’m a libertarian at heart. I realize that personal consumption—roughly two-thirds of all economic activity—drives the economy. Moreover, if someone really wants to devote his life to accumulating more, more, more, that’s his right.
As John Maynard Keynes put it, “It is better that a man should tyrannize over his bank balance than over his fellow citizens.”
(Although, personally, I’ve never met anyone who obtained lasting satisfaction with a Visa or Mastercard.)
Second, I’m not immune to the occasional bout of affluenza myself. I rarely pass a bookstore or record shop, for example, without poking my head inside. And whenever I leave Barnes & Noble, the clerk at the register always asks the same thing:
“Would you like us to double-bag that for you?”
We all have to consume to survive, of course. But Madison Avenue is right there beside us, aiding us, abetting us . . . giving us a not-so-subtle push.
Marketers want to convince us that our lives would be so much better if we would only just drive this car, drink this lite beer, use this antiwrinkle cream, or fly these friendly skies.
Every day we are bombarded: billboards, Internet banners, TV and radio commercials, newspaper and magazine ads. You can’t even get away at a public beach. Single-engine planes criss-cross the sky trailing banners, “Joe’s Crab Shack: All You Can Eat $17.99” or “2-for-1 Drinks All Day at Bennigan’s.”
Advertisers are getting more sophisticated, too. The new science of neuromarketing is designed to help retailers unlock the subconscious thoughts, feelings, and desires that drive our purchasing decisions.
Using magnetic resonance imaging scanners to record brain activity in minute detail, marketers now measure how their products affect the brain’s pleasure centers. In short, they are creating products and advertising that stimulate the production of dopamine.
And it works. Today psychologists routinely talk about “retail therapy,” where consumers shop just to get a short-term high to ward off boredom or the blues.
How do we resist?
First by recognizing our limits, both financial and material. After all, it really doesn’t really take a lot of money to meet our needs.
Many of the other things we covet don’t hold our attention long. Recognize that and you may conclude that they aren’t worth the time and trouble it takes to acquire them.
As the philosopher Bertrand Russell wrote, “The man who acquires easily things for which he feels only a moderate desire concludes that the attainment of desire does not bring happiness. . . . He forgets that to be without some of the things you want is an indispensable part of happiness.”
A well-lived life cannot just be about competing against others for resources. He who dies with the most toys doesn’t win.
As Laurence G. Boldt writes in The Tao of Abundance,
The psychology of plenty differs fundamentally from the psychology of scarcity. If I view my life as a struggle to sustain my existence in an unfriendly world, then intimidation, competitiveness, and greed make sense. If I view life itself as a gift, attitudes of praise, thanksgiving and responsibility naturally follow.
It’s only human to want to better our material conditions, of course. But the relentless quest for more often undermines our quality of life. Successful lives are built not bought. And an over-consumptive lifestyle ultimately limits our choices.
As Russell said, “It is preoccupation with possessions, more than anything else, that prevents us from living freely and nobly.”
Curing affluenza means dropping the chains of mindless consumption. It means recognizing that lives based on having are less free than those based on doing or being.
Wise men and women have known this for millennia.
In 400 B.C.E., the Greek philosopher Diogenes taught that no man needed much—and that we shouldn’t complain of material loss. He once went to Athens with his slave Manes, who ran away. Diogenes shrugged off his ill fortune saying, “If Manes can live without Diogenes, why not Diogenes without Manes?”
In It’s All In Your Head, Stephen M. Pollan and Mark Levine relate another story about the famous ascetic:
Diogenes is sitting on the side of the road eating his simple meal of porridge. A court philosopher sees him and comes over to chat. “You know, Diogenes, if you learned to play up to the king like the rest of us, you wouldn’t have to live on porridge.” Diogenes doesn’t even glance up from his bowl; he just says, “If you learned to live on porridge, you wouldn’t have to play up to the king.”
Reasonable, affordable consumption means less struggle, less debt, less hassles, less stress.
It also grants us more time—and with it the opportunity for new experiences, better relationships, and greater personal freedom.
As Oscar Wilde said, “The true perfection of man lies not in what man has, but in what man is.”
WHY MONEY WON’T GET YOU TO “LEVEL THREE”
In the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson argued that life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are our inalienable rights.
You have life and more liberty than your ancestors could possibly have imagined. Not just freedom from tyrants and feudal lords, but freedom from backbreaking labor, forced conscription, arranged marriages, widespread banditry and injustice, religious persecution, economic privation, and the threat of dozens of now-curable diseases.
Happiness, on the other hand, is a little trickier.
Notice that Jefferson was wise enough to say we don’t have a right to happiness itself, just the pursuit of it. After all, it can be elusive . . . especially Level Three.
According to Daniel Nettle, a lecturer in Psychology at the University of Newcastle in Britain and the author of Happiness: The Science Behind Your Smile, there are three levels of happiness.
Level One is the happiness of momentary feelings. This is the enjoyment we take in a good movie, a game of tennis, or a meal spent in the company of friends or family. This type of happiness is immediate but transient. Whenever you experience joy or pleasure, you have reached Level One.
Level Two is more cognitive. It involves judgments about feelings. If you are satisfied with your life, if you reflect on your pleasures and pains and feel that, overall, the balance is positive, you’ve reached Level Two. You are likely to report a general sense of satisfaction or wellbeing.
And Level Three? According to Nettle, you reach Level Three only when you feel like you are flourishing, fulfilling your life’s potential. Level Three is about living the highest quality life.
What is that, exactly?
I’m tempted to paraphrase Louis Armstrong. Asked by an interviewer to define jazz, he replied “Man, if you gotta ask, you’ll never know.”
Clearly, however, a high-quality life is not synonymous with simply making a lot of money.
I’m not an idealist arguing that money doesn’t matter. It does.
Money determines your neighborhood and the house your kids grow up in. It determines whether they go to college and where. It can decide whether you get a good doctor or an amazing doctor. If you need a lawyer, it determines whether you get an ambulance chaser or the best defense attorney money can buy. It provides freedom, security, and peace of mind.
In short, money matters. But it doesn’t buy genuine love or friendship. It won’t solve your problems, end your worries, fix your marriage, make you “a success,” or even make you more charitable. People without money often imagine it will do all these things. It won’t.
That’s because money doesn’t change you. It magnifies you, making it clear to everyone who you really are. In the end, you are who you are because of the choices you make, not the amount of money you have.
As author and TV personality Larry Winget says, “If Paris, Britney and Lindsey weren’t rich, they would still be crashing cars and acting stupid at Wal-Mart instead of on Rodeo Drive. You just wouldn’t know about it. . . . Money doesn’t make you stupid. It just gets your picture taken more often.”
Some folks might wonder what creates high-level satisfaction, if not the blessings that money can buy.
In his book
EconoPower: How a New Generation of Scientists is Transforming the World, my friend and colleague Mark Skousen provides a pretty good answer. The four elements of happiness, he says, are:
1. Rewarding and honest employment
2. Recreation
3. Love and friendship
4. Spiritual development
Notice that number 1 is a pretty tough hurdle for retirees, and helps explain why so many slip into depression after leaving the workforce.
Notice, too, that none of the four elements requires money. (Though I’ll concede that if you’re broke, your recreation is more likely to be hiking, swimming, or reading than yachting and racing thoroughbreds.)
Perhaps the best description of Level Three happiness was put forward by Aristotle a few thousand years ago in the Nicomachean Ethics.
The Greek philosopher argued that we seek happiness in all the wrong places. We chase pleasure, excitement, and profit. Not that these things aren’t enjoyable. But they don’t create lasting contentment, because they are not what matters most.
What matters most, says Aristotle, is realizing your potential, living up to your values, and following your conscience. It’s these things that create “the good life.” It’s these virtues that lead to a deep and abiding sense of happiness (what Nettle calls Level Three).
Following the dictates of conscience is never easy, of course. In many ways we will fall short. Still, it’s better to fail at what is worth pursuing than to succeed at what is not.
Where is your conscience leading you today? Chances are you already know.
As General Norman Schwartzkopf famously said, “The truth of the matter is you always know the right thing to do. The hard part is doing it.”
THE GREAT MYSTERY
There has been a lot of fear and uncertainty in the financial markets recently.
We’re struggling with the worst credit crisis since the 1930s. The S&P 500 has plunged. Investor’s Business Daily reports that over 90 percent of all stock and bond mutual funds lost money last year.
Millions of investors have rushed into Treasuries. Many will stay there until they find someone who can tell them when the coast is clear again.
Unfortunately, that person doesn’t exist.
I was an investment advisor and portfolio manager for many years. I’ve been a financial writer for the past eight. I don’t know what the market is going to do in the short term. And I’m not the least bit reluctant to admit it. Because no one else knows either.
However, there are plenty of people on Wall Street—and in the financial media—who make a good living pretending to know or, in some cases, deluding themselves that they really do know.
This is a deadly mindset. (Pride isn’t one of the seven deadly sins for nothing.)
Anyone can make a good market call. But no one can accurately predict the economy, interest rates, inflation, the value of the dollar, or the financial markets.
Count yourself a sophisticated investor the day you finally say to yourself, “Since no one can tell me with any consistency what lies just ahead for the economy and the stock market, how should I run my money?”
This inability to know what the future holds drives many investors to distraction. (Or, in some cases, the poor house.) But, to a great extent, markets are always inscrutable.
As Jason Zweig recently wrote in the Wall Street Journal, “Uncertainty is all investors ever have gotten, or ever will get, from the moment barley and sesame began trading in ancient Mesopotamia to the last trade that will ever take place on Planet Earth. If tomorrow were ever knowable with absolute certainty, who would take the other side of the trade today? . . . The only true certainty is surprise.”
When I began studying the world’s great investors more than two decades ago, I soon discovered that they used many different investment strategies. But they all approached the market with a deep sense of humility.
Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing, said, “If I have noticed anything over these 60 years on Wall Street, it is that people do not succeed in forecasting what is going to happen to the stock market.”
Warren Buffett, the world’s richest man and chairman of Berkshire Hathaway, once told shareholders, “We’ve long felt that the only value of stock forecasters is to make fortune tellers look good. Even now, Charlie [Munger] and I continue to believe that short-term market forecasts are poison and should be kept locked up in a safe place, away from children and also from grown-ups who behave in the market like children.”
In his book One Up On Wall Street, Peter Lynch, the best mutual fund manager of all time, wrote, “Thousands of experts study over-bought indicators, oversold indicators, head-and-shoulder patterns, put-call ratios, the Fed’s policy on money supply, foreign investment, the movement of the constellations through the heavens, and the moss on oak trees, and they can’t predict the markets with any useful consistency, any more than the gizzard squeezers could tell the Roman emperors when the Huns would attack.”
These men understood that humility is essential to investment success—as it is to so much else in our lives.
Humility doesn’t mean selling yourself short or not exercising your talents to the fullest. It means making an honest appraisal of the limited knowledge, experience, and understanding that we all bring to life.
It means having a realistic perspective, understanding that—whatever our particular talents—we are not the center of the universe. “We are all worms,” Winston Churchill remarked. “But I do believe I am a glow-worm.”
Humility is becoming. It wears well. Truly confident individuals don’t need to brag or boast. It’s much more attractive for people to discover your many charms on their own.
Secure individuals don’t lord their status over others. Even if you are a truly one-in-a-million kind of guy, in a world of six billion people that means there are thousands more just like you.
A companionable friend or dinner guest knows better topics of conversation than himself. “There are two types of people in this world,” observed Frederick L. Collins. “Those who come into the room and say, ‘Well, here I am!’ and those who come in and say, ‘Ah, there you are!’ ”
Could anyone really prefer spending time with the former?
A modest attitude also demonstrates maturity. “Let us be humble,” said Jawaharlal Nehru. “Let us think that the truth may not perhaps be entirely with us.”
Live long enough and you’re likely to learn that life is one long lesson in humility. Things don’t always turn out like we planned . . . or even how we could have imagined.
Our happiness is determined, in large part, by how we handle these inevitable surprises. Because uncertainty will always be with us. Perhaps that is why Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist George Will once described his idea of heaven as “infinite knowing.”
Recognizing the limits of our knowledge is invaluable, whether we’re analyzing problems, figuring out relationships—or even puzzling over the big existential questions. Why are we here? Where did we come from? What’s it all about?
Scientists, philosophers, and theologians have struggled with these for thousands of years. And still wrestle with them today.
As Nobel Prize-winning particle physicist Leon Lederman wryly observed, the universe is the answer. What we still don’t know is the question.
This humble attitude has been embraced by great minds throughout history, from Aristotle to Newton to Einstein to Gandhi.
As Sioux Indian chief Ota Kte observed a century ago, “After all the great religions have been preached and expounded, or have been revealed by brilliant scholars, or have been written in books and embellished in fine language with fine covers, man—all man—is still confronted with the Great Mystery.”
THE DECENT DRAPERY OF LIFE
During tough times, the nation’s Presidential contest follows a familiar plot.
The candidate out of office invariably raises the age-old question, “Are you better off now than you were four years ago?”
When politicians pose this question, we know they are asking us to do a quick economic calculation. Is your salary higher? Is your home worth more? Is your 401(k) rising in value?
Given the bruised condition of the U.S. economy, housing market, and stock market, millions of Americans recently responded with an emphatic “no”—and a few overripe tomatoes.