CONTENTS
PART I: THE MAKING OF A LEGIONNAIRE
1 Crossing the Line
2 The Power of Tradition
3 Basic Training
4 Into the Legion
PART II: LIFE IN THE LEGION
5 Barrack-Room Culture
6 The Legion on Campaign
7 Depression and Desertion
PART III: THE LEGION AT WAR
8 An Empire in Africa
9 The Conquest of Indochina
10 The First World War: Death in the Trenches
11 The Inter-War Years
12 The Second World War: A House Divided
13 Tragedy in Vietnam
14 The End in Algeria
15 Post-Colonial Conflicts
Postscript
Appendix
Source Notes
Select Bibliography
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Adrian D. Gilbert has written extensively on military history. Among his books are Britain Invaded, an imaginary narrative of a German invasion in 1940; The Imperial War Museum Book of the Desert War, featuring first-hand accounts from British forces in North Africa, 1940–42; Sniper: One on One, a history of sharpshooting and sniping; and POW: Allied Prisoners in Europe 1939–45.
VOICES OF THE FOREIGN LEGION
THE FRENCH FOREIGN LEGION IN ITS OWN WORDS
Adrian D. Gilbert
This eBook is copyright material and must not be copied, reproduced, transferred, distributed, leased, licenced or publicly performed or used in any way except as specifically permitted in writing by the publishers, as allowed under the terms and conditions under which it was purchased or as strictly permitted by applicable copyright law. Any unauthorised distribution or use of this text may be a direct infringement of the author’s and publisher’s rights and those responsible may be liable in law accordingly.
Epub ISBN: 9781845968717
Version 1.0
www.mainstreampublishing.com
This edition, 2010
Copyright © Adrian D. Gilbert, 2009
All rights reserved
The moral right of the author has been asserted
First published in Great Britain in 2009 by
MAINSTREAM PUBLISHING COMPANY
(EDINBURGH) LTD
7 Albany Street
Edinburgh EH1 3UG
ISBN 9781845965761
No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any other means without permission in writing from the publisher, except by a reviewer who wishes to quote brief passages in connection with a review written for insertion in a magazine, newspaper or broadcast
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Imperial War Museum is always a treasure trove of information on any military subject, and my thanks go to the keepers and staff of the departments of Printed Books and of Documents and to the Sound Archive. The British Library and the London Library were also invaluable as a source of essential books.
I would also like to thank Brigadier Tony Hunter-Choat OBE of the Foreign Legion Association of Great Britain, who kindly pointed the way towards a number of former legionnaires. Among these, I would especially like to thank Dave Cunliffe, Carl ‘Jacko’ Jackson, Matt Rake and David Taylor. My thanks also extend to Mrs E. P. Deman (widow of Peter [formerly Erwin] Deman) and Kevin Foster for their permission to use material via the IWM’s Sound Archive. My gratitude also goes to the help provided by others who wish to remain anonymous.
I am grateful to the authors, agents and publishers who have granted me permission to use material from the following works: Leslie Aparvary, A Legionnaire’s Journey (Detselig Enterprises); Gareth Carins, Diary of a Legionnaire: My Life in the French Foreign Legion (Grosvenor House, © 2007 – author website: www.diaryofalegionnaire.com); Blaise Cendrars, Lice (Peter Owen); Anthony Delmayne, Sahara Desert Escape (Jarrolds), reprinted by permission of the Random House Group; Christian Jennings, Mouthful of Rocks: Through Africa and Corsica in the French Foreign Legion (Bloomsbury); Simon Low, The Boys from Baghdad (Mainstream); Pádraig O’Keeffe with Ralph Riegel, Hidden Soldier: An Irish Legionnaire’s Wars from Bosnia to Iraq (The O’Brien Press Ltd, Dublin © Padraig O’Keeffe and Ralph Riegel); Simon Murray, Legionnaire: An Englishman in the French Foreign Legion (Sidgwick & Jackson); John Parker, Inside the Foreign Legion: The Sensational Story of the World’s Toughest Army (Piatkus/Little Brown); Jaime Salazar, Legion of the Lost: The True Experience of an American in the French Foreign Legion (Berkley Caliber), represented by Andrew Lownie; Howard Simpson, Dien Bien Phu: The Epic Battle America Forgot (Potomac Books); Zosa Szajkowski, Jews and the French Foreign Legion (KTAV); Jacques Weygand, Légionnaire: Life with the Foreign Legion Cavalry (© Jacques Weygand, 1952), reproduced by permission of Chambers Harrap Publishers Ltd; James Worden, Wayward Legionnaire (Robert Hale, © 1988), reproduced by permission of James Worden and Pollinger Ltd.
I would also like to thank publishers and agents for their help in attempting to secure copyright holders of these works: Jo Capka, Red Sky at Night and Ernst Löhndorff, Hell in the Foreign Legion (HarperCollins); Pierre Leuliette, St Michael and the Dragon, John Lodwick, Bid the Soldiers Shoot, Susan Travers, Tomorrow be Brave (Random House); Adrian Liddell Hart, Strange Company and Colin John, Nothing to Lose (Orion Publishing Group); G. Ward Price, In Morocco with the Legion (Random House and Curtis Brown).
Every effort has been made to clear permissions, and all omissions are unintentional. If permission has not been granted please contact the publisher, who will include a credit in subsequent printings and editions.
Thanks too to my agent Andrew Lownie, and to Graeme Blaikie, Iain MacGregor and Kate McLelland at Mainstream Publishing. And a special thanks to Victoria.
CHAPTER 1
CROSSING THE LINE
Simon Low made his decision to join the French Foreign Legion while sitting in a south London pub in 1988. After seven years’ service in the British armed forces he wanted another challenge, and putting down his unfinished pint he returned to his flat, packed his belongings and took the train for Paris. It was a hard-thought choice, however, and Low had misgivings as he took the metro across the city to the Legion’s recruiting office at Fort de Nogent:
Never has a tube ride been so nerve-wracking; counting the stations still to come, I was aching to get there and get it over with. At the same time, I didn’t want the journey to end. When it did, I rapidly climbed the stairs two at a time to ground level. I asked an official-looking chap in a 50-pence-shaped, peaked cap directions for the Foreign Legion. ‘Où Légion Étrangère?’ Without batting an eyelid, he pointed along a tree-lined road, ‘Par là, par là’ [There].
Two minutes’ brisk walk found me staring at a sign above two large wooden arched fort gates – Légion Étrangère. Taking a deep breath and holding my grip over my right shoulder, I walked towards the small door set into the larger wooden gates, my heart beating ten to the dozen, and rapped loudly with my knuckles. Immediately, a slit in the door snapped open. A pair of eyes peered from within, scrutinising me. I waited for a few seconds while the eyes continued their hard stare, then, pointing to myself, I said, ‘Moi, Légion Étrangère.’
The eyes disappeared, and there was a scraping of bolts before the small wooden door opened inwards. It revealed a legionnaire in combats and kepi, assault rifle slung across his chest. He motioned me to step inside, where I was first searched and then led to a bare stone-arched room. He uttered two words: ‘Assis toi ’ [Sit down]. I sat on one of the old wooden chairs positioned against the wall. The legionnaire then left, closing the solid wooden door with a resounding bang. Now alone, I looked towards the ceiling, stretched my legs out in front of me and breathed a massive sigh of relief. I had done it. I had crossed the fateful line and into the unknown.
Low’s description would find an echo in almost all those who have crossed that line. David Taylor had to overcome second thoughts when he volunteered in 1983:
It was a very daunting walk up the hill from the station to the old fort with its huge wooden gate about 20 feet high. I did what I’m sure many guys did, and that is turn around and walk back to the station to have a beer and think things over. I then went back up, knocked on the door, and went through it right into the Legion.
By its very nature, the Legion has accepted men from all nationalities and walks of life. In the past, if the volunteers were between 17 and 40 years old and were able to meet the Legion’s physical requirements they were seldom rejected. The idealistic adventurer – of the type made famous in the Beau Geste novels of P. C. Wren – was actively discouraged, however. As far back as 1890, Frederic Martyn was surprised to find his recruiting officer trying to dissuade him from signing the standard five-year contract. The officer – believing the well-bred Martyn would find life unduly hard – remarked: ‘There are many, too many, who join the Legion with no sort of qualification for a soldier’s life, and these men do no good to themselves or France by enlisting.’ Similar reservations were displayed by a Legion non-commissioned officer (NCO), when a be-suited, public school-educated Simon Murray announced his intention of joining the Legion in February 1960:
There was a sergeant sitting behind the table who looked me up and down and said nothing. I broke the ice and said in English that I had come to join the Foreign Legion and he gave me a look that was a mixture of wonder and sympathy. He spoke reasonable English with a German accent and asked me, ‘Why?’
I said something conventional about adventure and so on and he said I had come to the wrong place. He said five years in the Legion would be long and hard, that I should forget the romantic idea that the English have of the Legion and that I would do well to go away and reconsider the whole thing. I said I had given it a lot of thought and had come a long way and eventually he said ‘OK’ with a sigh and led me upstairs and into an assembly hall.
When, in 1999, American would-be legionnaire Jaime Salazar said that he too was looking for adventure, he was openly laughed at by his recruiting NCO, a Japanese caporal-chef. But after some preliminary questions, the corporal handed copies of the contract for Salazar to sign:
The pen trembled in my hand. God alone knew what I was agreeing to and what rights I was signing away. But once I had signed, I felt an indescribable release. I’d finally done it!
I was made to change into a green tracksuit smelling of sweat and vomit with a hole in the crotch, and was thrown into a room with the other new arrivals, a collection of humanity’s rejects. The Legion has always had a bizarre mix passing through its gates, from the legendary gentlemen who joined in top hats and tails to men who arrived in tatters and signed with an X.
One after another, men in the new intake returned from the bureau waving pieces of paper printed with their nom de guerre, the new identity under which they were joining the Foreign Legion. Some were guys with a past that they needed to put behind them; some were even French. According to its founding statutes, the Foreign Legion is an army of non-French mercenaries. On paper, apart from the officers, there are no French nationals serving in the ranks. Any Frenchmen are listed as Belgians, Swiss or French-Canadians. Recruits are [sometimes] given names based on their real initials so that I, as Jaime Salazar, would become Juan Sanchez. Jasper Benson, a black American, was given the name James Bond.
The offer of anonymity has been central to the Legion. It has given men an opportunity to escape their pasts, and, under a different name, forge a new identity. In Western Europe and the United States, a prime motivating factor for signing up has been a love of adventure; in an increasingly safe world the Legion remains one of the ultimate tests of manhood. But economic and social problems have played their part as well. This was certainly the case for former British paratrooper Carl Jackson:
In some ways I joined the Foreign Legion to forget; as it gave me time not to think about the many problems I had left behind me. After 12 years’ service in the British Army I was back in my home town of Aberystwyth, back to the reality of electric, gas and water bills – something we never had to deal with in our protected Army environment. However, it was a very disappointing homecoming as I didn’t feel the ex-military were being well treated; I couldn’t find work and nobody wanted to know.
My first marriage had just broken up, which had not been very amicable, with Brett, my young three-and-a-half-year-old son, being right in the centre of an argument concerning right of access, which made life extremely stressful. I felt that if I didn’t sort my life out soon I was probably going to end up being the guest of Her Majesty’s Prison Service in Swansea, getting three square meals a day and sewing mail bags for a living. In the end I drew my own conclusion, which was to get away and start afresh.
Regarding the Legion as a whole, poverty and political repression have been the most persuasive recruiting sergeants, and not the betrayals in love that became so popular in Legion novels. During the nineteenth century – and well into the twentieth – pay was so poor that it was only the most desperate who volunteered for economic reasons: in order to put clothes on their backs and food in their mess tins. An old maxim ran: ‘La Légion c’est dur – mais gamelle c’est sur!’ [The Legion is hard – but food is for sure!]
Erwin Rosen, a German journalist who had travelled extensively in America, signed up for the Legion in 1905. At a recruiting office in Belfort he was pushed into a room to await his medical examination, and there was shocked at the desperate state of his fellow recruits:
The atmosphere of the close little room was unspeakable. It was foul with the smell of unwashed humanity, sweat, dirt and unwashed clothes. Long benches stood against the wall and men sat there, candidates for the Foreign Legion, waiting for the medical examination, waiting to know whether their bodies were still worth five centimes daily pay.
One of them sat there naked, shivering in the chill October air. It needed no doctor’s eye to see that he was half starved. His emaciated body told the whole story. Another folded his pants with almost touching care, although they had been patched so often that they were now tired of service and in a state of continuous strike. An enormous tear in an important part had ruined them hopelessly. These pants and that tear had probably settled the question of the wearer’s enlisting in the Foreign Legion.
A dozen men were there. Some of them were mere boys, with only a shadow of beard on their faces; youths with deep-set hungry eyes and deep lines around their mouths; men with hard, wrinkled features telling the old story of drink very plainly.
Adrian Liddell Hart – son of the military theorist and historian Sir Basil Liddell Hart – volunteered in 1951. He analysed why men joined the Legion. Having accepted that some would have enlisted out of economic necessity, he suggested two other reasons:
There are a number of men who join for strictly professional reasons. They are men who want to be professional soldiers and cannot soldier in their own countries or have decided that it is anyhow better to soldier in the Legion. For them the Legion has certain concrete advantages. There are plenty of opportunities for active service – and for action. Promotion in the non-commissioned ranks can be rapid, with corresponding benefits, and for some, at least, it is easier to become an officer in the Legion than it might be in their national forces.
In the second place there remain a proportion of men who have sought sanctuary in the most literal sense. A few of them, even today, are escaping from their police for civil offences. Many more are escaping from their governments for political reasons. In the modern world the Legion is not, perhaps, such a sure refuge in this sense as it used to be. But there is no doubt that it still makes the effort to protect this kind of individual, once he is accepted, against the ever-increasing power of the modern state. And whether he likes the Legion or not, it is surely better than sitting in a concentration camp or, in many instances, in an ordinary gaol.
Since the 1960s – and the Legion’s move from Algeria to France – improved pay and prospects have made the Legion attractive to a wider range of economic migrants, and following the collapse of the Iron Curtain in 1989 many of these have come from Eastern Europe. Another inducement has been the offer of French citizenship when the legionnaire’s contract has been successfully completed. In the twenty-first century, the ranks of the Legion are being joined by increasing numbers from South America, Asia and Africa seeking a better life in the West.
Something of the difference between Westerners and those from more economically deprived countries can be seen in a conversation between the university-educated Jaime Salazar and a former Polish law student called Sadlowski, who rebuked Salazar for his reason for joining:
I can’t understand what you wanted to join up for. You had a good life in America. It was totally different for me; the Legion’s my lifeline. Things back in Poland are desperate – there’s crime and corruption everywhere. The only people making money are the mafia. I liked my studies but how could I live on three hundred US dollars a month? If I make the cut, I’ll join the parachute regiment where I hear you can earn fifteen thousand francs a month and more on mission to Africa!
If economic deprivation provided a steady stream of recruits then war, revolution and other political upheavals produced the great surges of enlistment that became such a part of the Legion’s history.
White Russians entered the Legion in large numbers in the early 1920s, following their defeat by the Bolsheviks in the Russian Civil War. After both world wars, displaced Germans continued to volunteer for the Legion, despite their recent enmity with France. The Soviet invasion of Hungary in 1956 saw Hungarians leave their homeland for the Legion. Similarly, there were influxes of Czechs after the repression of the ‘Prague Spring’ in 1968, and Portuguese recruits after the 1974 overthrow of the Spinoza regime. In 1981 Colonel Robert Devouges, a veteran Legion officer, said of recent upheavals: ‘We reflect the troubles of the world. Laos, Cambodia, Bangladesh – you name the event, and we’ll have the men.’
These surges of manpower from specific nations inevitably modified the character of the Legion – before being absorbed into it with minimal trouble. A. R. Cooper, a legionnaire in 1914, was bemused by the strange national, social and political mix of the Legion when he rejoined in 1919:
I found that half my Legion comrades were Germans, the very people I had been trying to kill for four years in the bloodiest war of all time. I had to admit that the Germans were the better elements. The majority had belonged to the Spartacist group of Marxists, and others were monarchists who had enlisted to avoid serving the new [German] republic. The monarchists were mainly former Prussian officers. Most of the Spartacists, on the other hand, were schoolteachers, intellectuals and engineers.
Russians had been virtually unknown in the Legion before the war. They flocked to the service of France after the failure of the White Russian movement, many of them still wearing Cossack uniforms with cartridge belts across their chests. Here was a paradox: Spartacist revolutionaries and White Russians, opponents of Communism, working amicably together in a force that also included Prussian aristocrats.
Apart from its obvious multinational nature, the Legion was marked out by the social range of its recruits, even if the majority came from the lower rungs of society. While officers within the Legion numbered several princes, as well as the future King Peter of Serbia and Pierre Messmer, a French prime minister, the ranks of enlisted men included Giuseppe Bottai, a former education minister in Mussolini’s government, Shapour Bakhtiar, the Shah of Iran’s last prime minister, and Siegfried Freytag, a Luftwaffe ace (102 official victories) who joined the Legion after the Second World War, served in Indochina and died in the Legion’s retirement home in 2003. The Legion traditionally attracted writers and artists, among whom were the German painter Hans Hartung, the American poet Alan Seeger, the German writer Ernst Jünger and the Hungarian intellectual Arthur Koestler.
From Fort de Nogent, and the other recruiting centres dotted across France, the recruit is despatched to the Legion’s headquarters and administrative centre at Aubagne, a few miles north of Marseilles. The recruit will spend around three weeks at Aubagne, where his suitability for the Legion is assessed, before going on to commence basic training at Castelnaudary, where he is classified as an engagé volontaire (EV). Christian Jennings, a British volunteer in 1984, described his arrival at Aubagne after a coach trip from Paris:
Driving up to the gates of the camp, I saw my first legionnaire in parade uniform; he was wearing a white kepi, a green tie and blue cummerbund. He saluted the coach and we drove through the gates and up a hill past the enormous parade ground at the far end of which I could see the Monument aux Morts, the memorial to every dead legionnaire. It took the form of a huge bronze globe supported by an enormous stone plinth. It had originally occupied a position at Sidi-bel-Abbès, but when the Legion left Algeria it had been dismantled stone by stone and brought to its present resting place at Aubagne. Behind it was a stone wall on which was written in bronze letters the motto of the Legion, ‘Legio Patria Nostra’ [the Legion is Our Country].
It was only 7.30 a.m. but already it was getting hot. The camp was full of pine trees and flowerbeds of bougainvillea and hibiscus. Square white buildings, three storeys high, sat at regular intervals on the slope, all looking down towards the parade ground. Uniformed legionnaires marched around, and there was a group of convicts from the regimental prison in filthy fatigues and greasy boots who were emptying the dustbins and sweeping the roads. A body of soldiers in sports kit marched past in a slow, rhythmic pace, singing loudly. They were all in step and looked very smart. We drove to the top of the road and drew up outside a compound surrounded by a wire fence; inside was a large white building surrounded by an expanse of gravel on which a huge group of people were drawn up in lines. This was the ‘Section Engagés Volontaires’, the department that dealt with all prospective recruits.
Pádraig O’Keeffe, previously a hotel chef in Cork, recalled his time at Aubagne in 1991:
I spent three weeks in Aubagne, and it was very much an acclimatisation for Legion life. You learned to march, you learned to keep your gear in order, you learned to salute properly and you began your introduction to what it meant to be a legionnaire. And I had my first introduction to the dreaded corvée – the cleaning routine. Being on corvée duties meant spending your whole day cleaning – first your barracks, then the floor, then the toilets and finally, perhaps, the entire parade ground. If one thing in Legion life was to be avoided at all costs, it was corvée duty, and, needless to say, that was impossible.
The prime reason behind the volunteer’s stint at Aubagne has been to weed out the unsuitable, and each recruit is subjected to a series of basic physical, intelligence and psychological tests. In the modern, post-colonial period the number of would-be legionnaires has not diminished and the Legion can afford to be choosy in who it takes on, as Major Karli, a vocations officer during the 1990s, outlined:
There is a certain turnover in the Legion and the gaps have to be filled but at present we have more candidates than we can use. We are now accepting about one in eight, so you can see the selection is fairly rigorous. The person’s background is taken into consideration. Previous military experience is helpful but not necessary. Civilian experiences can be just as important. We may even accept someone fresh out of school if we feel he has the right attitude and potential to make it as a legionnaire.
While at Aubagne the recruit also undergoes rigorous security checks by the 2ème Bureau – the intelligence section nicknamed the ‘Gestapo’ – as O’Keeffe explained:
This was a series of interviews, which bordered on interrogation, about your previous life. The first session lasted about three hours and was like an A–Z of your life to date. It was a grilling that went on for several further sessions over an entire week, and if any aspect of your story didn’t gel, you were out. The Legion interrogators were incredibly adept at indentifying recruits who were trying to hide something in their past – in most cases a criminal conviction or an ongoing problem with the police. If they were suspicious, they could devote two entire sessions to asking the same question in about two hundred different ways. One of the worst crimes in the Legion is to be caught lying, and it’s not something that would be sorted out the easy way – at the receiving end of a fist or boot.
Traditionally, the Legion was willing to turn a blind eye to recruits who had misunderstandings with the law in their own countries – unless, of course, it involved murder (and other serious crimes). But the Legion insisted on knowing why recruits wanted to be legionnaires and any criminal past was a crucial factor in that.
Before Aubagne became the Legion’s home in the 1960s, its headquarters was at Sidi-bel-Abbès in Algeria. Recruits were assembled at Marseilles before being shipped over to Africa. Adrian Liddell Hart described his experiences in the old and squalid Fort St Nicholas in Marseilles:
In the dawn, through overcast days, in the chill, damp dusk as we gazed across the harbour at the pin-points of lights, through the bleak barrack-rooms hazy with the smoke of acrid French tobacco, would reverberate an interminable roll-call over the loudspeaker. Here and there figures would detach themselves from the windswept huddles and slip away to the orderly office. We might not see them again. An empty bunk that night, its rugs returned to the store and waiting for the next occupant, would remind us of final rejection.
We were not yet legionnaires. But we had ceased, for practical purposes, to be civilians. We were not citizens or even aliens. We were prisoners, it seemed, without the limited rights and minimum security which are generally enjoyed by prisoners, convicted or remanded. We were informed of no rights and assured of no prospects. We were liable to be kept in suspense and then rejected without ever knowing the reason.
Our daily lives were controlled by the large German corporal who had interviewed me on my arrival. As several hundred eccentrics and an unknown number of desperados from the ends of the earth were turning up each week, the corporal earned his modest chevrons. He relied on whistle and shout freely supplemented by his boot. Occasionally someone tried to resist. He would be hustled off by a group of legionnaires, who materialised at short notice, amidst a hail of blows. Sometimes he was not seen again. Sometimes he returned the worse for wear, from the cells, where it was rumoured others languished indefinitely.
Simon Murray also successfully went through the selection process in Marseilles. He wrote in his diary:
We leave for Algeria tomorrow. Excitement is running high. Imaginations are working overtime. We have been given Legion haircuts – clean sweep, bald as eggs, known as a boule à zero. We look more like convicts than ever. I am looking forward to getting out of this rat hole.
Reveille at five o’clock and we piled into trucks that took us down to the harbour. We left Marseilles under a clear blue sky aboard the SS Sidi-bel-Abbès, a 5,000-ton troop-carrier-cum-cattle ship. The sleeping quarters are in the bowels of the ship and consist of a thousand deckchairs facing in every direction and packed as tightly as sardines in a tin. I stood on deck until the last pencil-line of land became invisible. I said goodbye to old Europe and turned to face Africa and God knows what.
After a stormy Mediterranean crossing, Murray and his fellow recruits arrived in Oran, before being transferred, first to Sidi-bel-Abbès and then Mascara to undertake ‘instruction’. In today’s Legion, those who have passed the selection course at Aubagne are sent to Castelnaudary in south-west France to begin four months of hard basic training.
CHAPTER 2
THE POWER OF TRADITION
Before leaving Aubgane for basic training at Castelnaudary, the engagé volontaire (EV) will be taken around the Legion’s museum. This is not intended as a pleasant recreational trip, rather it is one of the first steps designed to inculcate the recruit with the mystique of the Legion, above all its separateness from any other military corps. British legionnaire John Yeowell, who signed up in 1938 and was sent to Sidi-bel-Abbès, described how the Legion used its past as a training tool:
We now began our period of indoctrination. It was to fill our heads with the traditions of the Legion. One of the first things they did was to take you around the museum of the Legion, the Salle d’Honneur, where the great battles of the past were described to us, along with exploits of the heroes. We saw the captured battle colours, ancient swords, rifles and other relics. They gave us each a little book with our names inscribed inside, which highlighted the Legion of the past. It really did work. Every day on the parade ground there was some kind of traditional activity going on with the Legion band playing all the trumpet calls which we had to memorise and which always ended with a performance of ‘Le Boudin’ [the regimental march]. It was all very moving. And the traditions of the Legion began to sink in.
Nearly half a century later, Christian Jennings was given the tour of the museum at Aubagne, as well as a two-hour lecture celebrating the Legion’s history:
We visited the Legion’s museum and wandered round looking at the different flags of the units which had fought all over the world for 150 years. There were displays of medals, weapons, uniforms and pictures. We went down into the crypt where the wooden hand of Capitaine Danjou [hero of the fight at Camerone] lay in a glass case. It was the focal point of the room, and whenever visiting dignitaries and military authorities came to visit Aubagne they would be taken down to the crypt where they would stand and salute the hand. There was a poem on the wall written by an American legionnaire called Alan Seeger during World War I:
But I’ve a rendezvous with Death
At midnight in some flaming town,
When Spring trips north again this year,
And I to my pledged word am true,
I shall not fail that rendezvous.
There were tattered flags from Dien Bien Phu and Algeria, and collections of medals belonging to famous Legion soldiers. I walked over and stood respectfully in front of Capitaine Danjou’s false limb. It was made of dark wood and looked like a graceful gorilla’s paw. I read another poem on the wall written by a God-fearing captain who had been killed in Algeria, in which he implored God to look sparingly on humble soldiers performing their divine task as warriors of Christianity. It effectively conjured up the mixture of religion, fighting prowess and romanticism which the Legion held so dear.
Central to the Legion’s idea of itself is the engagement at Camerone, fought in Mexico on 30 April 1863, when the Legion was part of an invading French Army attempting to set the Archduke Maximilian upon the throne of Mexico. Although the campaign ended in failure, the defence of Camerone has become a sacred event in the Legion calendar. A special Camerone Day is set aside on 30 April, and the following official account is read out to all men in the Legion:
The French army was besieging Puebla. The Legion had been ordered to protect traffic and ensure the security of convoys over seventy-five kilometres of road.
On 29 April 1863 the commanding officer, Colonel Jeanningros, was informed that a large convoy, carrying three million francs in specie, siege material and ammunition, was en route for Puebla. Captain Danjou, his second-in-command, persuaded him to send one company ahead of the convoy. No. 3 Company of the Foreign Legion Regiment was detailed but it had no officers available. Captain Danjou took command himself and 2nd-Lieutenants Maudet of the colour party and Vilain, the paymaster, volunteered to join him.
At 1 a.m. on 30 April No. 3 Company set off at a strength of three officers and sixty-two men. By 7 a.m. it had covered some twelve miles when it stopped to brew coffee at Palo Verde. At this moment the enemy appeared and fighting started at once. Captain Danjou formed square and, during his withdrawal, successfully repulsed several cavalry charges, inflicting his first severe losses on the enemy.
On reaching Camerone inn, a vast building including a courtyard surrounded by a 9-ft-high wall, he decided to dig in there in order to pin the enemy down and delay to the maximum the time at which the convoy might be attacked.
While the men were hurriedly organising the defence of this building a Mexican officer summoned Captain Danjou to surrender, pointing out the vast disparity of numbers. Captain Danjou replied: ‘We have ammunition and we shall not surrender.’ Then, raising his hand, he swore to defend himself to the death and required his men to swear the same oath. It was now 10 a.m. Until 6 p.m. these sixty men, who had neither eaten nor drunk since the previous day and despite extreme heat, hunger and thirst, defended themselves against 2,000 Mexicans – 800 cavalry, 1,200 infantry.
At midday Captain Danjou was killed by a bullet through the heart. At 2 p.m. 2nd-Lieutenant Vilain fell with a bullet in the head. At this point the Mexican colonel succeeded in setting fire to the inn.
Despite their sufferings, increased by heat and smoke, the legionnaires held on but many of them had been hit. By 5 p.m. there remained only twelve men to fight, grouped around 2nd-Lieutenant Maudet.
At this point the Mexican colonel assembled his men and emphasised to them the disgrace which would attach to them if they were unable to overcome this handful of brave men (a legionnaire who understood Spanish translated his speech as it was made). The Mexicans prepared for a general assault through the breaches which they had succeeded in opening but Colonel Milan first sent another surrender call to 2nd-Lieutenant Maudet. It was scornfully rejected.
The final assault took place. Soon there remained only five men around Maudet – Corporal Maine and Legionnaires Catteau, Wenzel, Constantin and Leonhart. Each still had one round in their rifles and their bayonets were fixed; in a corner of the courtyard, their backs to the wall, they faced their enemies; at a given signal they fired point blank at the enemy and then charged with the bayonet. Second-Lieutenant Maudet and two legionnaires fell, mortally wounded. Maine and his two legionaries were about to be massacred when a Mexican officer dashed forward and saved them, shouting ‘Surrender’. ‘We will surrender if you promise to collect and care for our wounded and if you leave us our weapons,’ Maine replied. The three men still had their bayonets lowered. ‘We can refuse nothing to men like you,’ the officer answered.
Captain Danjou’s sixty men had kept their oath to the end; for eleven hours they had held up 2,000 enemy, of whom they had killed 300 and wounded a similar number. By their sacrifice and by saving the convoy, they had carried out their orders.
The Emperor Napoleon III decided that Camerone be inscribed as a battle honour on the colours of the Foreign Legion and the names of Danjou, Vilain and Maudet be engraved in letters of gold on the walls of Les Invalides in Paris.
In 1892 a memorial was built on the scene of the fighting. Ever since then, when Mexican troops pass the memorial, they present arms.
In the early 1960s, foreign correspondent Geoffrey Bocca asked a group of legionnaires why Camerone was so important to them, especially when it was little more than a skirmish and virtually unknown outside the Legion. One of them, a Sicilian sergent-chef called LaBella, replied:
The appeal of Camerone to a legionnaire is as natural as instinct. He reaches out to it in his own heart, because it is part of his own pain. It is the great reminder to the legionnaire that the sand is always blowing in his eyes, the battleground is always ill-chosen, the odds are too great, the cause insufficient to justify his death, and the tools at hand always the wrong ones. And, above all, nobody cares whether he wins or loses, lives or dies. Camerone gives the legionnaire strength to live with his despair. It reminds him that he cannot win, but it makes him feel that there is dignity in being a loser.
As part of its separateness, the Legion likes to see itself as a family – albeit a rough one – in which every legionnaire is an exclusive member. James Worden, a former RAF officer who joined the Legion in the late 1950s, pointed out the legionnaire’s true loyalty to this extended family became apparent on completion of his basic training:
It is at this time that the almost fully trained recruit realises that, although on enlistment he swore an oath of allegiance to the French flag, that flag is wholly represented by the Legion, and only the Legion. He may be termed a soldier but he is not part of the French Army, and for him there will only exist the Legion and its officers. The French regular army is as remote as the man on the moon, and will not even exist in his mental make-up.
At the great military display in Paris on Bastille Day (14 July) the Legion brings up the rear of the march-past because of its unusually slow parade march, set at 88 paces per minute instead of the more usual 120. Along with its white kepi and distinctive parade uniform this is another means of keeping a distance between the Legion and the rest of the French armed forces. Dave Cunliffe, a sergeant in the 1990s, took part in two Bastille Day parades, where the crowd gave the Legion the loudest cheer:
On Bastille Day the Legion marches last down the Champs Elysées in Paris. There they exaggerate the slow march, instead of the Legion’s actual regulation 88 paces a minute they bring it down to 60-odd paces a minute for effect. You’re practically falling over, you’re going so slow. But it is pretty impressive, and it is good to be in that platoon or squad when you’re marching.
Raymond L. Bruckberger – an American traveller in North Africa before and after the Second World War, who knew the Legion well – wrote of the relationship binding all legionnaires:
From the highest to the lowest, there is a strong bond among legionnaires which is stronger than any solidarity of rank. A private in the Legion knows that his colonel prefers him to any officer who is not in the Legion. The Legion is like a large family that needs only itself to exist.
Bruckberger then went on to narrate a story illustrating the loyalty of legionnaire to legionnaire, regardless of rank:
In 1945, an agreement between the French and Russian governments provided for the repatriation of all French prisoners in Russian hands, and all Russians on French soil. A Russian commission visited the barracks of the Legion. It was received with perfect courtesy. It showed the colonel a list of Russians in the Legion. The colonel recognised all the names, but the commission must excuse him for at that hour of the day all the men were out for drill. He asked the commission to return the following morning and promised that all the men would be there. That evening he called all the men together, explained the situation and asked each one what he wanted to do. They all preferred the Legion to Russia. The colonel immediately changed all their names to others that had a French ring. When the Russian commission presented itself the next day, it was received with the greatest courtesy. ‘I’m terribly sorry,’ said the colonel, ‘but yesterday evening I imprudently told those men to be ready to appear before you in the morning. Last night, every one of the scamps deserted.’
The Legion has made a speciality of its stories – some apocryphal – which in various ways illustrate aspects of the corps. Colin John, a British legionnaire stationed in Indochina during the early 1950s, retold the well-known account of the legionnaire who was continually falling foul of authority:
Some time or another he visited a tattooist, and printed indelibly in letters an inch high across his right hand was the one word ‘Merde!’ [Shit!] This had somehow escaped notice at his medical examination, and later caused quite a bit of embarrassment. He was ordered to wear a glove on his right hand so as to avoid giving offence to officers when saluting. As he liked nothing better than giving offence, he was constantly losing the glove, and each time he was sent to prison for fifteen days.
Another popular anecdote was recounted by Legion historian Erwan Bergot, relating to the White Russian cavalrymen who joined the Legion in the early 1920s:
The story is told that one day, during an inspection at Sidi-bel-Abbès, a colonel was struck by the appearance of a recruit with the moustache of a Tartar and the beard of a prophet. The colonel asked: ‘What were you before you came here?’
‘I was a general, mon colonel.’
This story cannot be confirmed. What is certain is that, disregarding the strict discipline of the Legion and in the secrecy of the barrack room, a certain sergeant would come each evening to kiss the hand of a simple legionnaire and address him according to the ancient Cossack tradition as: ‘Monsieur le sotnik’ (a Cossack rank equivalent to captain). The sergeant had previously been his batman.
Among German legionnaires the story of the Prussian royal prince who had secretly volunteered in the 1880s remained in common currency for years, his identity only discovered after a heroic death fighting tribesmen in Algeria. The idea of redemption through combat – especially by a well-connected ne’er-do-well – found its way into many Legion narratives. This, of course, is not to say that they were not necessarily true. Zinovi Pechkoff, the adopted son of the Russian writer Maxim Gorki and a Legion officer who had lost an arm in the trenches in 1915, described the actions of an Italian legionnaire – a former First World War I officer – during the 1925 campaign against Rif tribesmen in Morocco:
Once, when we were on a long march, I saw him weary and tired, dragging along behind his section. I said to him: ‘I should like better to see you at the head or your section and not behind – especially you, an ex-officer, with all your decorations.’ But on the day that he was wounded I saw him at the head of his section, rushing forward, fearless of danger. Afterwards he wrote me a letter from hospital saying:
My foot is badly shattered, but I am recovering from the wound, and I hope to come back. The only thing I want to ask is – did you see me in battle? I would be so sad if you were left under the impression which you received when you saw me marching behind my section.
Then I received another letter from his father [a retired general], telling me that he himself had sent his boy into the Legion.
Please do not think that he is a criminal or a young murderer. He is not. He is young. He misbehaved himself. His passion for cards got the better of him and he did what a gentleman should not do. I paid his debts. Then I told him to join the Legion and if he did well for five years he could come back to his family. Now he is wounded. You write me that his conduct was brilliant. I am overjoyed, I am proud of him. He is once more my beloved Enrico. He will continue his service in the Legion and after the five years he will be once more accepted in the family.
The idea that the Legion offers a break with the past and a chance to begin anew has been taken up by many writers. The French author André Maurois put it more grandly than most in his preface to Pechkoff’s memoirs:
All civilisations have their sufferers. In every country in Europe, and without doubt in America also, live men for whom life is a penance. Some have been stricken down by misfortunes or by unforeseen happenings and the sight of the places where they have been unhappy has become unbearable for them. Others have suffered by their own mistakes or they have committed some act for which their consciences reprove them; they feel that, rightly, they are despised and they know that they can reconstruct themselves only by escaping from their pasts. Others, citizens of countries which have been overthrown, cannot adapt themselves to new conditions: their only resource is to expatriate themselves.
For all these beings, for all those whom Dostoevsky calls ‘The Insulted and Injured’, the Foreign Legion offers a refuge.
Adrian Liddell Hart developed the concept of the Legion as a psychological safe-haven:
The Legion is a refuge . . . As such it exists in a world where it becomes increasingly difficult for the individual to find a refuge. And it may even be surer to escape into the anonymity of suburbia than the anonymity of Sidi-bel-Abbès. But many people do not want to escape into nothing – they want to escape into a community, into a tradition, into a myth. Man needs to make a gesture.
Finally there is the idea that the legionnaires do not necessarily become better or wiser, but they become more integrated. In joining the Legion men do not join only an organised, disciplined institution; they enter a situation which is more or less recognised by the whole world and sanctified by its sacrifice. They belong – many for the first time.
The Legion claims to be something more than a military force. This claim is essential. However much it may fall short of the fulfilment, the Legion could scarcely exist without this aspiration, this mystique. And the strictly military exigencies are, to some extent, subordinated in practice to this human ideal.
A. R. Cooper, the British legionnaire who served during the inter-war period, provided this summary of what it was to be a soldier in the Legion:
Many legionnaires took a masochistic pleasure in an unhappy life. Attempted explanations are complicated by the fact that the Legion is composed of men of many races, whose origins, sentiments and ideas are totally different. This in itself gives the legionnaire an indefinable personality of his own.
The Legion is a refuge, a meal ticket, a place for rehabilitation. It can also be a profession. A man goes to it without identity papers, with the nationality of his choice, and shorn of criminal records. He leaves his past outside the recruiting office door. In the Legion one finds strange mixtures of good and bad, latent heroism, and sometimes a degraded soul. All these aspects, when fused together, emit an iron energy, an instructive zest for adventure, an astonishing fount of initiative and a supreme disdain for death. The composite legionnaire has all the sublime virtues brought out by war and displays virility and superiority. Yet he lives in a fantasy world, and if he is ever in trouble he will blame le cafard, a name adopted by legionnaires to mean a form of temporary madness peculiar to the legion brought about by a variety of circumstances, including boredom. But, above all, the men of the Legion religiously uphold their traditions and military integrity.
Most of today’s legionnaires tend to see the Legion and themselves in less highly wrought terms, although Christian Jennings provided this modern view of the Legion’s sense of itself:
Over the decades the Legion had developed its own kind of soldiering. It was not soldiering where all hung on victory or defeat, as in other armies, but rather a stylish profession of arms, aimed at bringing greater glory to France and to the Legion. As at Camerone and Dien Bien Phu, the cost was high; but the Legion in its purest tradition saw only merit in dying for France. Painted on the walls of a barracks in the last century had been the words, ‘Legionnaires, you are soldiers in order to die, and I am sending you where you can die.’
This was the essence of its self-glorification. It was an idea based on the lifestyle of the true legionnaire, who, before his time in the Legion, had been nothing, and therefore in the eyes of the Legion, anything he had done in his past life was immaterial. He only became whole in becoming a legionnaire.
The lines of a poem were written on a plaque at the end of our corridor, Lui qui est devenu fils de France, non par le sang reçu, mais par la sang versé (He who has become a son of France, not through blood received, but by blood spilt.) In our history lecture I grasped only the most basic nature of this warrior creed, but it was something which I was to find permeating the Legion at every level.
CHAPTER 3
BASIC TRAINING
E